Skip to content

Retention agency or freelancer: which one fits your store

Both can build good flows and send good campaigns. The difference is how much of the work one person can cover, and what happens when that person isn't available. Here's how to decide, including when a freelancer is the better call.

Three questions that decide it

How many skills does the work need?

Retention work spans strategy, copywriting, email design, flow building, segmentation, deliverability and, if you use them, SMS and WhatsApp. Ask which of these the person does themselves and which they'd hand off.

Who sets the direction?

Someone has to decide what to send, to whom and when. If that's you, a skilled pair of hands may be all you need. If you want someone else to own the plan, check that the person or team you hire actually does that.

What happens on a bad week?

People get sick, go on holiday or take on a bigger client. Ask how your calendar keeps running when that happens, whoever you hire.

A freelancer is likely the better fit if

  • You need one defined job, such as a set of flows or a template system.
  • Email isn't yet a big part of your revenue, so a lighter setup is enough.
  • Someone on your team owns the strategy and wants execution.
  • Your budget covers one person's time, not a team's.

An agency is likely the better fit if

  • You want one outside partner to plan, write, design, build and run email (and SMS or WhatsApp) together. Ask who on their team does each part; it depends on who is on the team.
  • A missed week of sending would cost you real revenue, so you need an answer to "who sends if someone is away?" Ask the agency; don't assume.
  • You'd rather not hire a copywriter, a designer and a Klaviyo builder separately and stitch their work together.

When we're the wrong choice

If all you need is one flow built, a good freelancer is probably the quicker, cheaper route. If your store is well under $50k a month, a full retention system is more than you need right now. We'd rather say that on a call than sell you more than you need.

Questions to ask either one

  • Can I see named case studies, and where do the numbers come from?
  • Is that revenue attributed by the platform, or tested against a holdout group?
  • Who will actually write, design and build my emails?
  • Will everything live in my own account, under my login?
  • Can I see emails you've built before we talk?

Frequently asked questions

Is an agency always more expensive than a freelancer?

It depends on scope. Compare like for like: an agency's price against every freelancer you'd need to cover the same work.

Can we start with a freelancer and switch later?

Yes. Make sure the account, flows and templates stay in your own login, so whoever comes next can pick them up. With us, your Klaviyo account and data stay yours, during and after.

Can we use both?

Yes, as long as one person or team owns the plan, so two sets of hands don't send conflicting messages.

Not sure which you need?

Book a call. Tell us what you send today and what you want email to do. If a freelancer would serve you better, we'll tell you.